​

Excerpt from Archaeology & Adventure Quarterly, July 2025

When it comes to legendary lost riches, Montezuma’s treasure has it all – a vast hoard of gold, a blood-soaked history, and a centuries-old curse (at least, if the stories are to be believed). For over 500 years, people have whispered about the lost gold of the Aztecs, supposedly worth billions in today’s money. But what is the real story behind this fabled treasure, and how did it capture the world’s imagination – including Rowan Mallon’s?

Montezuma II and the Aztec Empire’s Wealth

In the early 16th century, the Aztec Empire was at its zenith. Emperor Montezuma II (also spelled Moctezuma) ruled from the island city of Tenochtitlán, a metropolis of temples and palaces in the middle of Lake Texcoco (where Mexico City stands today). The empire spanned much of central Mexico, fed by tribute from conquered cities. Gold streamed into Tenochtitlán in the form of jewelry, idols, plates – not as currency, but as material for art and ritual. By all accounts, Montezuma’s treasury was overflowing with gold, jade, turquoise, and quetzal feathers. The opulence was so great that when Spanish conquistador Hernán Cortés and his small band arrived in 1519, they were stunned. One Spaniard wrote that the Aztec market displayed “more riches than the markets of Venice… enough to bewilder the mind.”

Of course, this awe quickly turned into greed. The Spanish had an unofficial motto: “We came for God, glory, and gold – but especially gold.” Initially, relations were cordial. Montezuma, curious or thinking the Spaniards might be messengers of a prophecy, welcomed Cortés into the capital. For months, the conquistadors lived as guests – until tensions exploded. In May 1520, during a religious festival, Cortés’s men massacred Aztec nobles (some say to seize the gold ornaments they wore). The Aztecs revolted furiously. Montezuma lost control of his city. He was killed under murky circumstances – either struck by Spanish blades or stoned by his own people for his perceived betrayal.

The Spanish, besieged and desperate, decided to flee Tenochtitlán under cover of night on June 30, 1520 – a disastrous retreat known as La Noche Triste (“The Night of Sorrows”). The conquistadors tried to carry off as much Aztec gold as they could. Famously, they loaded themselves with treasure until they could barely walk. As they snuck out across a causeway, Aztec warriors attacked. Chaos ensued: arrows flying, bridges collapsing, canoes of Aztec fighters overturning boats of fleeing Spaniards. Weighted down by gold, many Spaniards fell into the lake and drowned, the treasure sinking with them. Survivors reported that the causeway and canals were littered with glittering loot and corpses by dawn. Cortés escaped with only a fraction of his men; much of the plunder was lost in the waters.

When Cortés returned a year later with reinforcements and finally conquered the Aztecs in 1521, he expected to recover enormous wealth. But the storied treasure had vanished. The Aztec Empire fell, yet relatively little gold was found compared to the lavish descriptions. What happened to Montezuma’s riches? The Spaniards only recovered some – leading to suspicions that the Aztecs hid the rest.

Myths of the Lost Aztec Treasure

In the aftermath, legends sprang up to fill the gap in the record. Aztec survivors, so the stories go, gathered what treasure remained during the chaos and spirited it away. Some tales claim priests hid golden idols in secret caves; others say loyal warriors carried off Montezuma’s hoard to keep it from foreign hands. Over the centuries, Montezuma’s lost gold became a magnet for folklore:

• Sunken Treasure of Lake Texcoco: One longstanding theory is that most of the treasure lies at the bottom of Lake Texcoco, where the Spanish dropped it during La Noche Triste. Indeed, in 1981, construction workers in Mexico City unearthed a massive 1.9-kg bar of gold under what was once lakebed – testing confirmed it was Aztec gold, likely lost by Cortés’s men as they fled. If one bar survived, might there be more lying in the mud? Treasure hunters have dredged and metal-detected around the former lake over the years. While no dragon’s hoard has surfaced, every few years an artifact is found – a handful of gold beads here, a jade figurine there – fueling hope that Montezuma’s motherlode still slumbers beneath modern city streets.

• Buried in a Secret Tomb: Another legend speaks of a hidden chamber in the ruins of Tenochtitlán or nearby. According to this tale, as defeat loomed in 1521, Aztec priests gathered the empire’s holiest relics and gold, sealing them in a vault beneath the Great Temple. They allegedly laid a curse on it – anyone who disturbs the emperor’s gold shall suffer misfortune (the so-called Curse of Montezuma, a catchy idea that later treasure hunters certainly played up). While archaeologists have indeed found offerings of gold and jewels in the Templo Mayor (the Aztec Great Temple) during excavations, no giant royal cache has turned up there. Still, whenever a new tunnel or chamber is discovered under Mexico City, speculation bubbles: “Have they finally found Montezuma’s tomb?”.

• Carried North to Safety: The most adventure-packed legend claims that a band of Aztec warriors escaped with Montezuma’s treasure and marched north, far beyond the reach of the Spaniards. Some versions even say they took Montezuma’s remains with them, to bury the emperor and his riches together in a sacred, hidden place. Various Indigenous oral histories in northern Mexico and the U.S. Southwest mention a group traveling with heavy burdens around that time. Could the Aztecs have transported tonnes of gold to some remote canyon up north? It sounds far-fetched – imagine hauling all that loot hundreds of miles on foot while being pursued – but it has inspired intrepid souls to search deserts and mountains from Arizona to Utah for Aztec gold.

Each legend adds its own dramatic flourish – ominous petroglyphs warning “death to invaders,” golden idols guarded by spirits, secret maps passed down through generations. None of these have been verified by historians, but they make for ripping yarns. Importantly, the Spanish chronicles do mention that a great quantity of treasure was unaccounted for after the conquest. So while the details are mythical, the central premise – treasure went missing – is true.

Treasure Hunts Through the Ages

Montezuma’s lost treasure tantalized not just historians and romantics, but also those willing to dig (sometimes literally) for answers. Here are a few notable chapters in the treasure hunt:

• Spanish and Mexican Attempts: Right after the conquest, Cortés himself tried to recover the lost gold from Lake Texcoco, using captured divers. They found some, but by his own admission, much was beyond reach. In the centuries that followed, rumors persisted. During colonial times and after Mexican independence, various expeditions – some official, many illicit – poked around old Aztec sites. In the 1700s, a Spanish viceroy supposedly drained a small section of the old lake and found nothing but mud and a few pottery shards. In the 1800s, as Mexico City expanded, construction occasionally yielded a shiny trinket, spurring treasure fever. The Mexican government generally frowned on treasure hunting (it liked to keep national antiquities under state control), but that didn’t stop fortune seekers from digging quietly at night in chapels or old pyramids hoping to strike Montezuma’s jackpot.

• The Sierra Madre and “Montezuma’s Head” (1840s): During the Mexican–American War (1846–48), an intriguing tale emerged. As the story goes, a wealthy Mexican aristocrat named Don Joaquín had been obsessed with Montezuma’s treasure. He believed some of it had been hidden in the northern frontier, near a craggy peak called Montezuma’s Head in what is now Arizona. Don Joaquín reportedly forced Apache laborers to excavate caves in the Sierra Madre for clues. They did uncover a stash of gold – possibly treasure hidden during earlier Spanish evacuations – which he began hauling away. But fate intervened: Apache warriors attacked his party to reclaim their land and the gold. In haste (and fear), Don Joaquín’s men are said to have re-buried the sacks of treasure in a secret canyon and fled. Only one wounded servant survived the ambush and made it back to Mexico City, carrying a crudely drawn map and a wild tale of a hidden hoard in northern deserts. Decades later, in the 1880s, that servant’s grandson (so it’s told) tried to retrace the map to find the gold, but the Apache territory was still dangerous – he never found the cache, and the map was lost. This legend, blending war history with Aztec gold, has never been substantiated, but it put the idea of “Montezuma’s treasure in Arizona” on the map – literally. Even today, treasure hunters explore canyons around the U.S.–Mexico border, searching for caves that match the old descriptions.

• Freddy Crystal and the Kanab Mystery (1920s): One of the most famous (and quirky) episodes was the hunt led by a prospector named Freddy Crystal in Kanab, Utah. In 1914, Freddy arrived in the small Utah town with a sensational claim: while in Mexico, he had found ancient Aztec tablets or maps that pointed to Kanab’s barren hills as the hiding place of Montezuma’s treasure. He convinced the townspeople that a nearby rock formation (Three Lakes Canyon) hid an entrance to an Aztec mine. Enthralled by the story (and potential riches), locals helped him dig. For months they excavated caves and found what Freddy said were “Aztec markings” on the walls. But alas – no gold. By the late 1920s, the dig was abandoned, and Freddy Crystal vanished as mysteriously as he’d come. Many considered him a con man or a crackpot. Still, the tales of strange symbols and tantalizing tunnels persisted. Kanab’s legend of Aztec gold lives on; even in recent years, some explorers with metal detectors have sought any trace of Freddy’s elusive trove. Though nothing conclusive was found, the story shows how enduring the Montezuma myth is – it travelled over a thousand miles to Utah and took root. Modern archaeologists note that there’s no evidence the Aztecs made it that far north. But try telling that to treasure hunters with a dream!

• The Curse and the Cave of Chapultepec (1940s): A lesser-known yarn from the 1940s places Montezuma’s treasure beneath Chapultepec Hill in Mexico City – the site of the imperial palace of Maximilian and later the presidential residence. During WWII, an eccentric historian claimed he decoded a Jesuit cipher that revealed a cache of Aztec gold hidden in a cave under Chapultepec, guarded by a curse. He and a small team secretly tunneled into the hill. Allegedly, they encountered deadly traps: one man was injured by a fall, another fell ill (cue curse talk). Ultimately, local police discovered the unauthorized digging and halted the operation. No treasure was recovered, and the documents that spurred the attempt were dismissed by experts as forgeries. Still, this episode added to the “curse” lore – newspapers at the time ran tongue-in-cheek headlines like “Montezuma’s Revenge – in a Cave, Not a Cup!” (a play on the Montezuma’s Revenge nickname for traveler’s diarrhea).

Each new expedition, whether fueled by genuine research or get-rich-quick fervor, only amplified the legend. By Rowan Mallon’s youth in the early 20th century, Montezuma’s lost treasure had become the ultimate symbol of an adventurous quest – a real-world El Dorado that tantalized with a mix of history and mystery. Popular novels featured intrepid explorers following ancient maps, pulp magazines ran covers of mummies guarding piles of Aztec gold, and scholarly debates raged about whether the treasure was real or myth. It’s little wonder that Rowan, restless and romantic, developed a lifelong obsession with Montezuma’s Gold